Should find 'third way' on legal reform

By Morton Kondracke, Columnist
Tuesday, November 03, 2009 | No comments posted.

Font Size: Shrink Font Enlarge Font | Submit your news
There’s an important task congressional moderates can perform on health-care reform besides fighting the public insurance option: Find a middle ground on medical malpractice.

Even President Barack Obama ought to join the cause and go beyond the tepid studies that he’s instituted and push for real centrist legal reforms.

“Third way” legislation is available — developed by legal reformer James Wootton and backed by several provider, physician and advocacy groups — that would make it possible to prevent and resolve medical mistakes with less resort to costly litigation.

The effort, backed by Xerox Corp., the pharmacy benefit manager Medco Health Solutions and the American College of Cardiology, is also designed to advance use of health information technology by limiting the ability of trial lawyers to raid information systems for lawsuit fodder.

A model bill, the Patient Safety and Compensation Act, promotes physician apologies, early settlement offers, mistake-prevention discussions, use of independent experts and comparability standards for damage awards.

It’s an alternative to the endless battle between doctors and trial lawyers, Republicans and Democrats, over “junk lawsuits” and the right to recourse for victims of medical negligence.

For years, Republicans and the American Medical Association have been pushing a national $250,000 cap on noneconomic damages (“pain and suffering”) in malpractice cases.

About half the states have followed California’s example in enacting caps, but nationally, the cost of malpractice insurance for doctors keeps soaring — along with the expensive practice of “defensive medicine,” the ordering of unneeded tests and procedures strictly to avoid lawsuits.

Medical malpractice happens, people suffer and die — perhaps 100,000 a year from avoidable medical errors. They deserve recompense.

But it usually takes three to five years to win a court case. Many victims are discouraged by the ordeal. And when they win an award, more than half of it customarily goes to pay legal and administrative costs.

On the other side, doctors — especially neurosurgeons and obstetricians — may pay up to $200,000 a year for malpractice insurance. AMA surveys show that the fear of getting sued leads 80 percent to 90 percent of physicians to practice defensive medicine — the cost of which is variously estimated at $20 billion to $200 billion a year.

If it’s somewhere in between, that’s $100 billion a year or $1 trillion over 10 years — more than the $900 billion ceiling that Obama has decreed for health-care reform.

Thirty-five states have passed laws protecting doctors who apologize for errors from having their words used against them. Virginia and Florida have no-fault “birth funds” that compensate families for neurological injuries to infants during childbirth.

Wootton, once president of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s Institute for Legal Reform, said his purpose is “to change the litigation culture in American medicine.”

In medicine, he said, “there is a code of silence enforced by defense counsels and the medical-insurance industry when there is a medical error in a hospital — they are told not to talk about it without a lawyer present.”

That’s part of what his proposal is designed to stop. It’s also designed to advance health IT — the key to quality control, pay-for-performance medicine and the spread of best practices.

“Obama is counting on electronic medical records, but are doctors and hospitals going to invest in it if a trial lawyer in one case decides to file a class action and can access every electronic record a provider has?

“Even some of the best hospitals in the country, I know, are keeping some things out of their systems because of fear of electronic discovery,” he said.

Before Congress and the president complete the health-care reform process this year, they need to take decisive action on the malpractice reform front — not kick it into the future with mere studies. It’s not too late.

(Morton Kondracke is executive editor of Roll Call, the newspaper of Capitol Hill.)
Previous
Next

Have you checked out The World Link Forums?

Comments

The comments below are from users of theworldlink.com and do not necessarily represent the views of The World or Lee Enterprises. Participation Guidelines

Note: There is a maximum of 200 words per comment. If you wish to post more, please visit our forum.
Comment Policy

The World welcomes your comments about stories, and we encourage a robust dialogue on this site. All comments must meet reasonable standards of decency and civility.

Please follow these basic rules:

  • No defamatory comments about individuals or businesses.
  • No deliberately false information.
  • No obscenity or racially offensive language.
  • No harassment, verbal abuse, threats or personal attacks.
  • No information that invades another person's privacy.
  • No business solicitations or charitable solicitations.
Comments that violate these standards will not be posted. Users with repeated violations may be banned from future posting.

Comments will be approved throughout the day during business hours. After hours and weekend comments may not appear until the following business day. It may take a couple of hours before comments are approved.

The World generally does not edit comments, but we reserve the right to edit any comment that does not meet our standards.

Close Guidelines

No comments posted.


*Member ID:
*Password:
 

Not already registered?

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!



*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

*First Name:
*Last Name:
Would you like to be added to our mailing lists?
Daily Headlines
Breaking News
Special Offers
 
Advanced Search
Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH

Blogroll

Most Popular

Polls

» View Past Poll Results
» Suggest a Poll

Marketplace

Special Sections

More Special Sections