Tribe OKs gay marriage


Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 136 comment(s)

Font Size: Shrink Font Enlarge Font |

Related Links

PORTLAND (AP) — The Coquille Indian Tribe, based on the southern Oregon coast, recently adopted a law recognizing same-sex marriage, and its first such wedding is set for next spring.

Oregon voters amended the state constitution in 2004 to prohibit gay marriage. But as a federally recognized sovereign nation, the tribe is not bound by the Oregon Constitution.

American Indians are “sensitive to discrimination of any kind,” said Ken Tanner, chief of the Coquilles.

“For our tribe, we want people to walk in the shoes of other people and learn to respect differences. Through that, we think we build a stronger community,” he said.

The Coquilles are believed to be the first tribe to legalize same-sex marriage. Three years ago, a lesbian couple in Oklahoma tested a loophole in the Cherokee Nation’s law that defined marriage as between two people enrolled in the tribe.

The tribe’s clerk denied the couple’s marriage certificate, prompting a lawsuit, and the Cherokee Supreme Court eventually sided with the couple. But they never submitted the marriage certificate to the county clerk, which would have taken the issue outside the tribe. The tribal council later adopted a law banning same-sex marriage.

Becky Flynn, regional director of Basic Rights Oregon, a gay rights advocacy group, said Wednesday the impact of the Coquille law is likely to be minimal beyond the couple and the tribe.

The federal government has the legal right to deny recognition to same-sex marriages under the Federal Defense of Marriage Act passed by Congress in 1996. The tribe concluded that the act may bar the Coquilles from conferring federal benefits or money on same-sex spouses, said Melissa Cribbins, assistant tribal attorney.

The first couple to get married under the new law is expected to be Jeni and Kitzen Branting, whose maiden name is Doyle and who legally adopted Jeni’s last name three years ago. Kitzen is a member of the tribe; Jeni is not.

Kitzen Branting, 25, said she doesn’t expect anything beyond tribal rights for her partner.

“For me, the important thing wasn’t about rights or the benefits,” she said. I just wanted the tribe to say ‘Yes, we recognize that you are just as important as any other tribe member, and we will treat you and your spouse as we treat all tribal members.”’

The couple is planning a May wedding at the tribe’s plankhouse, a common gathering place for the Coquilles. They’re inviting between 100 and 150 people.
Previous Email this story to yourself or a friend Print this story Next

Have you checked out The World Link Forums?

Comments

The comments above are from users of theworldlink.com and do not necessarily represent the views of The World or Lee Enterprises. Participation Guidelines

Note: There is a maximum of 200 words per comment. If you wish to post more, please visit our forum.
Comment Policy

The World welcomes your comments about stories, and we encourage a robust dialogue on this site. All comments must meet reasonable standards of decency and civility.

Please follow these basic rules:

  • No defamatory comments about individuals or businesses.
  • No deliberately false information.
  • No obscenity or racially offensive language.
  • No harassment, verbal abuse, threats or personal attacks.
  • No information that invades another person's privacy.
  • No business solicitations or charitable solicitations.
Comments that violate these standards will not be posted. Users with repeated violations may be banned from future posting.

Comments will be approved throughout the day during business hours. After hours and weekend comments may not appear until the following business day. It may take a couple of hours before comments are approved.

The World generally does not edit comments, but we reserve the right to edit any comment that does not meet our standards.

Close Guidelines

rebecca from oz wrote on Sep 17, 2008 5:00 AM:

Wow I am impressed. Thats really cool. But omgawd all the negative commenters. How is allowing gay marriage a bad thing? Amyone who brings up the 'drop in moral standards' thing - i cant think of a period in history where moral standards were oh so perfect so thats just crap! Also not everyone believes and follows whats in the Bible so bringing up religion is silly. There is a reason Church and State were seperated long ago folks.
If people love each other and want to live their lives together whether its man/woman, man/man or woman/woman they should be allowed to. Its not harming anyone. There are far worse things in the world to worry about.

Bandon Reader wrote on Sep 13, 2008 12:13 PM:

Love is God Given, and we are all connected, like it or not. Lack of Understanding and Compassion, and Fear block love which can create Hate. If you are not victimized, let it be.

To OPEN MINDED wrote on Aug 30, 2008 9:25 AM:

BOY YOU ARE "OPEN MINDED" IF YOU THINK THIS WHOLE SITUATION ISN'T "REPULSIVE" ..........
GUESS WE KNOW WHAT YOU ARE.....

THIS IS THE PROBLEM WITH THE WORLD TODAY, TOO MUCH "OPEN MINDNESS", NO MORALS, ANYTHING GOES ATTITUDE, OUR POOR CHILDREN DON'T KNOW WHAT TO THINK ANYMORE, NO GOOD ROLE MODELS FOR THEM IN THIS CORRUPT SOCIETY....

marcus wrote on Aug 29, 2008 5:51 PM:

dear going into hiding-

I think you really need to go see a psychologist. You are so insecure that you might disown your own tribe because they are accepting people for what they are? You think people might "make fun of you on the street?" You have the same mentality of a person thinking Indians shouldn't marry whites. Think about it. Your severe case of homophobia screams you aren't really "HETEROSEXUALL."

Here We Go wrote on Aug 29, 2008 5:43 PM:

At least the two women CAN'T get a marriage licesense in the State Of Oregon. I say Mr.Tanner should step down for allowing this to happen when the people of OREGON voted down gay marriage in 2004.

wow wrote on Aug 29, 2008 5:25 PM:

I cannot believe the things I am reading. I doubt any of you people have any right to judge. I give a high five to the tribe!!! If it's not hurting you the dont worry about it!!! It is NOT your life to even be judging others. Im sure none of you are perfect little angels and why do we care what you have to say. IT IS NOBODIES business to worry about. I am not judging you nor do I care what you do in your own life so do not judge me or my life.!!! Turn your head in disgust, I am sure I would do the same if i saw any of you, I dont believe I would approve of some of the aspect of your lives so dont approve of mine just dont worry about my life!!! i rather be gay and happy that be straight and miseriable like most of you are. GROW UP AND MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS!!!!!

JT wrote on Aug 29, 2008 1:34 PM:

To GOING IN TO HIDING: As a Tribal Member myself, I, too am upset that the members themselves did not get to vote. Just as the entire state populations get a say in what laws are passed, I think we should've gotten the same treatment. On the other hand, I support gay marriage, and because of all you closed-minded people, I am somewhat happy that the entire Tribe did not get to vote, for fear that it wouldn't not have passes. You think it's all for insurance reasons? Are you married? Did you and your spuse get married for insurance reasons? Most likely not, and neither are these couples. What's the difference? Maybe I should disenroll from the tribe b/c I'm embarrassed to have people like you be a part of it. Sound rediculous? Listen to yourself.

Going into hiding.... wrote on Aug 29, 2008 11:05 AM:

I am a member of the tribe and was horrified to read this had passed. I signed a petition to have this go to general vote for all the tribal members to decide on. I hate the fact that I am now going to be known for being in the tribe of gay marriage. I can say now this is all for insurance reasons. If they are not married the "partner" will not receive coverage, this is just a way to get around paying for coverage. I have also thought of dis-enrolling in the tribe so I am not going to be made fun of walking down the street from people who know me. I AM GOING TO SAY THIS NOW-I DO NOT SUPPORT THEIR UNION OR ANYONE ELSE WHO IS NOT A HETEROSEXUALL COUPLE!

Love is normal. wrote on Aug 29, 2008 1:28 AM:

How can anybody say this is not normal? true, there are less gays out there than straights. but they have the same feelings of love as any heterosexual out there,except it's towards the same sex. And that's a tiny difference.
I don't see how anybody can be so harsh or mad. They're the same as you, they're human.Now if they figured out how to live forever, then we can all be mad. but until then get over it. Complaining or saying it's a sin,not normal, or morally wrong won't make them think "oh this is wrong, I think I'll be straight now." it doesn't work like that.
Homosexuals are here and everywhere might as well get used to it because you can't change their life. Live your own life and stop worrying about others and puttin theirs down. They're doing the best they can, just as you are.

JT wrote on Aug 28, 2008 9:32 PM:

TO GRANDPA WHO IS SICK TO HIS STOMACH...

Who are any of us to say what is "normal"?? How does teaching acceptance and love hurt our children?? If anything, you are teaching them intollerance and hate. And "They just want attention"? How about they just want to be treated like humans, as they are? They are not trying to flaunt anything, they are standing up for their right as a human being. And you, my hateful friend, are what makes me sick to my stomach!

Open-Minded wrote on Aug 28, 2008 6:02 PM:

To JT wrote on Aug 28, 2008 10:41 AM:
There should actually be MORE comments on this and people should be more outraged than accepting of this situation. What is wrong with this, is it is hurting our children, teaching them this is NORMAL (like they are teaching them in school now) when it IS NOT NORMAL... I don't care myself what people do in their homes, but don't bring it out in society and push it in our faces, I DON'T WANT TO SEE IT AND DON'T WANT MY GRANDCHILDREN TO SEE IT. And as far as marriage, why, why, no need for it. Just want attention is all. If you all think this is so great, go see some gay pride or other gay parades and you come away completely SICK TO YOUR STOMACH, they are so repulsive.....big jokes actually, and they love to flaunt it in our faces, and you think thats normal??


I find your ignorance and judgemental attitude repulsive. Who are you to judge anyone?

Sad wrote on Aug 28, 2008 4:38 PM:

That some of you people are chasing others away from religion ENTIRELY, with your extremism. And you wonder why some of just completely don't care anymore about what your God says. You lose credibility all the time with these wedge issues, and this forum is a perfect example.

sar wrote on Aug 28, 2008 3:18 PM:

what difference does it make to you really??? Try and live your life and leave everyone elses alone....

common sense wrote on Aug 28, 2008 3:07 PM:

Those of you who are so outraged by the "gay lifestyle" should get a clue.

Obviously you don't like to think of two men sleeping together. Well, the two men probably don't like to think about sleeping with a woman either. Why? Because people are born that way...you don't choose what grosses you out or what you are attracted to.

What if a majority of the world was gay but you were straight. Would your "straight lifestyle" then be a "choice"?

Now imagine the hatred these people face, especially by many of you christians who are are supposed to be some of the most loving people on earth but turn out to be some of the most hateful and intolerant.

dear hatemongers wrote on Aug 28, 2008 2:56 PM:

Christianity is irrelevant as it is not a part of law. If you want a religious theocracy, move to Iran or Sudan. You self-righteous "moralists" think you are so much better than others and spend more time judging and hating than loving. You should be ashamed of yourselves for beating down and bashing two consenting adults who love each other.

I guess most of you people who are so obsessed with hating gay marriage and gay people just lack the mental capacity to put yourself in other peoples' shoes.

To JT wrote on Aug 28, 2008 10:41 AM:

There should actually be MORE comments on this and people should be more outraged than accepting of this situation. What is wrong with this, is it is hurting our children, teaching them this is NORMAL (like they are teaching them in school now) when it IS NOT NORMAL... I don't care myself what people do in their homes, but don't bring it out in society and push it in our faces, I DON'T WANT TO SEE IT AND DON'T WANT MY GRANDCHILDREN TO SEE IT. And as far as marriage, why, why, no need for it. Just want attention is all. If you all think this is so great, go see some gay pride or other gay parades and you come away completely SICK TO YOUR STOMACH, they are so repulsive.....big jokes actually, and they love to flaunt it in our faces, and you think thats normal??

ORNM wrote on Aug 28, 2008 8:33 AM:

While I do not support gay marriage and the gay lifestyle, I do support all Sovereign Tribe Nations.
I also wonder how many folks know that gay and lesbian marriage was tolerated by tribes far back in the past? That's right. Originally they were called "Two-Spirits" and were allowed to have spouses of the same sex. I've read many stories about lesbian warriors who were as fierce as any of the men and gay men as feminine as the ladies. It wasn't until the Christians beat it into the tribes that gay marriages stopped.
I am a christian who has evolved. Hate the sin, love the person.

To C Shupp wrote on Aug 28, 2008 7:10 AM:

I agree with you. and WE ARE ALREADY PAYING THE PRICE OF ALL THE IMMORALITY GOING ON IN THE WORLD TODAY.
No, none of us are perfect and we don't have to be judging, to point out the things that are wrong, and this is one of them. Like you said, anyone can twist the Bible around to their advantage, and make it sound like what they are doing is ok, but they really know better and just want to do "what feels good to them" and then try to justify it with their own interpetation of the Bible. BUT it doesn't work that way.....
This is one of the things that bothers me, making children think that anything goes and you can get away with anything. They have to have questions in their minds, that they don't always express when they see people of the same sex "together" and "marrying"... and then everyone trying to make out like it is "normal". What are we doing to our children....

To JT wrote on Aug 28, 2008 6:55 AM:

SAME THING .......

NB wrote on Aug 28, 2008 6:54 AM:

I CANNOT BELIEVE THERE ARE SO MANY COMMENTS THINKING THIS IS JUST GREAT !!!
What is wrong with people anymore ???
No wonder the world is having so many problems, our morals are declining and everyone thinks anything goes anymore. God is hurting that his childred have strayed so far from him

JT wrote on Aug 26, 2008 10:50 PM:

I just can't believe that there are over 100 comments for this, and only 13 about the sex offender...

TB wrote on Aug 26, 2008 6:03 PM:

I have friends who are gay,BUT that doesnt mean I support gay marriages or the lifestyle and they know this and "don't" shove it down my throat and try to make me believe in it(cause I dont believe in it nor do I approve),I figure in the end...WE ALL will be judged..some of us MORE harshly than others..so I'm not going to waste my time complaining over this topic.

in shock wrote on Aug 26, 2008 1:07 PM:

TWO FEATHERS...

Why can’t you find ONE person to LOVE - dedicate your life to caring for that ONE person - man or woman. Gay or straight- to lower the age to 13 - OMG - why - so they collect welfare benefits and early? 13 year olds need to be in school - not playing house. And then to add that MULTIPLE partners should be allowed - this world is already a mess. Kids don't need to be exposed to that type of lifestyle at such a young age.
As for 'stealing of the land' - get over it... i work for a living - and i have legally purchased my land - i did not just walk by it one day and decide to squat and say it was mine. I worked for it - and i will continue to work for it.
Kids need to grow up first- not fight over the right to be married at 13 - or have a relationship with multiple partners - shoot - i have a hard enough time with one partner!

Long Gone wrote on Aug 26, 2008 10:41 AM:

I left Coos County the minute I graduated high school. Growing up I just knew that the whole world couldn't be as narrow minded, racist, and Hateful as the coastal town I had been raised in for 18 years. Now I have lived quite a few places and I can tell you I was right. I'm not saying by any means that people support gay marriage everywhere, obviously, but at least they have the common sense to think of the words they say before spewing their ignorance and hate. Maybe you don't realize how you sound on here but it is embarrassing. Most of you people on here don't even know gay people or how they live, mostly because people in this area are forced to keep it a secret. So get out in the world, you are not the moral authority and it's a Big Ole World of all kinds of different and amazing people out there! If you didn't judge so harshly maybe they would enlighten you.

to over run wrote on Aug 26, 2008 9:56 AM:

Every town or city in the world has transients, it's a fact of life. You are not so exclusive in Coos Bay. Get over it or move the the wilderness, that way you won't have to judge other people and they won't have to deal with your ignorance.

Marijuana is starting to become decriminalized in many places around the world because it is morally wrong to imprison people for simple pot possession.

You've made it clear you are a racist and a homophobe as you are fearful "your" city will attract more homosexuals or native americans.

Please take your fascist mentality somewhere else.

CB Native wrote on Aug 26, 2008 7:01 AM:

The Tribe is not in the buisness of issuing Marriage licences so these women will still have to be legally married where they can. Then the Tribe will recognize them as "Married". The ceremony will be for the friends and family who wish to witness their commitment to each other.

over run wrote on Aug 26, 2008 3:29 AM:

1 - the coast gets loads of transients due to our milder climate.

2 - Our state essentially legalizes marijuana, encouraging droves of pot heads to come here.

3 - No doubt gay indians from all over the country will now flock here.

Not going to be much room left for employed non-drug using straight people.

ToPastor Jim wrote on Aug 25, 2008 10:02 PM:

if god created this universe along with everything in it and homosexuality is actually a "sin" then he wouldn't have created those feelings and attractions toward the same sex.
And if god is a fact then why has science proven that we came from evolution? science is a fact.
I'm not saying that god or any devine thing is non existant. sometimes I do believe that there is a "big man upstairs". But I don't see how anybody can live their life by a book written thousands of years ago and it wasn't even written by himself. But that's just my opinion.
why can't you just accept others as human beings and love them even if they're sinners? they're trying to make a happy life for themselves and do what they feel is good in their hearts just like you are. Except maybe serial killers and rapists and such.
In the end we're all the same. we all use the restroom, sleep, eat, breathe and pump blood. just because you believe in something a lot of people don't it doesn't make you any better.

nonpatron wrote on Aug 25, 2008 9:39 PM:

Do you think the Coquille tribe chose to
do make this decision so that they can get more people to come to their Casino?
The tribe is hurting because of the economy and all the money they invested in their new addition. I for one will definitely will not go to and spend my money there.

COQUILLE HOME GAL wrote on Aug 25, 2008 8:03 PM:

IF ANY OF YOU KNEW ANYTHING ABOUT INDIAN TOLERANCE, THEY DIDN'T THINK IT WAS A BAD THING FOR A PERSON TO BE WHO THEY WANTED TO BE..THEY JUST THOUGHT IT WAS NORMAL TO BE DIFFERENT.

Here We Go wrote on Aug 25, 2008 7:03 PM:

Let's put something worth reading up here instead of this "GARBAGE"

CB Lifer wrote on Aug 25, 2008 2:56 PM:

Oh yeah, and MY Bible also says that "whoever is without sin cast the first stone"-so, I'll not be casting any stones! Pastor Jim, couldn't have said it better. My Bible also says "Judge not lest ye be judged" - so it clearly is not my place to judge anything anyone else says or does. Too many Bible thumping self righteous people make too many people run from God.

leave it alone already.... wrote on Aug 25, 2008 12:58 PM:

I can't stand people who shove their religion/beliefs down the throats of those who see things in another way. Just because the bible is your way, does not mean that it is THE way. Christianity is not the only religion/belief that exist. Leave it alone. Saying that homosexuality is a "sin" or wrong is like saying that people who are born with a physical or mental trait/condition,eye or hair color, or all the other many things that a person is born with is a "sin". Homosexuality is NOT a choice. And no, I am not gay. Yes, the law is the LAW, but things change. Leave this happy couple alone and let them live their lives. They pay taxes, vote, join the service, go to war, and do everything else that american's do. Why can't they be married and adopt children like everyone else? Love is love, and that is what I believe in. I have both gay friends and gay family. I hope that someday they too will be able to marry the one that they love.

Congrats Kitzen & Jeni, best of luck in the future.

NB wrote on Aug 25, 2008 11:52 AM:

When you throw out the Truth, you have nothing left but a lie. When you throw out the Light, you have nothing left but darkness. There is no middle ground. Opinion is NOT fact. God is.

CB Lifer wrote on Aug 25, 2008 11:48 AM:

I think that the bottom line here is not so much the "gay issue" as much as the "we passed a law to not allow this" issue. I am not responsible for what part my forefathers may or may not have in the "Indian wars". I live here, my ancestors have lived here many many moons, came out in wagon trains, blah, blah, blah. I still do not believe that the "sovereign Indian nation" should be allowed to break the laws the majority have voted in. AS for my belief's I DO believe in God, and believe it is wrong, but that part is between the people and God, not for me to judge. I am one of the weird one's though, and DON'T try to cram it down someones throat, it's a choice. My comments are based on the "laws of the state", not so much my belief system. Who else will not have to follow the law?????

kat wrote on Aug 25, 2008 10:47 AM:

Good for you and good for all of us coquille tribe!!! Thank you for doing the right thing.

And Jess B. - couldn't agree with you more. i was going to say the same things but see that you've got it covered!

Pastor Jim wrote on Aug 25, 2008 10:36 AM:

To all of you trying to create a "God issue" with homosexuality, I must ask you to actually please read and UNDERSTAND your Bible. There is only one condition that the Father cannot accept and that is a person choosing to not be reconciled to Him. God is working His own plan, we are not going to bring about the destruction of the world. God is in full control of the ultimate result of this world. Homosexuality is a sin, as is the other 100 things most people do everyday. No more, no less. It will not keep them from a relationship with God.

Ben wrote on Aug 25, 2008 10:18 AM:

If LIFE doesn't begin at conception then why have Birth Control pills?
Psalm 51

CB Native wrote on Aug 25, 2008 7:38 AM:

To Al the pal
Get over yourself. Why not talk to a few of our elders in our Tribe before you open your mouth. Yes there is Native Americans that have had their land taken away.They are very much alive and would gladly school you.

JT wrote on Aug 24, 2008 9:33 PM:

To all of the religious bible pushers- Religion is a BELIEF. It is not fact. What you believe is fine, just don't push it on others. I, for one, do not believe in God for my own personal reasons, but I never tell people that they should 'bleieve' the same. People are entitled to their own opinions and beliefs. As a Ko'Kwel member, I am happy for this couple, and the others in the Tribe. And-the Tribe as a whole did not vote on this, it was a decision made by 4 people. I think that the entire Tribal Coquelle population should have been included in the vote, yet don't at the same time, b/c of all the closed-minded people. It's the 21st century people...

why cant.. wrote on Aug 24, 2008 9:20 PM:

everybody just quit with the "white man stole my land" stuff?
It was a horrible thing and I feel bad that my ancestors could do that.
But now the tribes have casinos, liquor stores/bars, and they can make their own laws. So why are you all still complaining? It's not going to give you your land back or all the buffalo and other wildlife game.
It's like all the african americans complaining about how they were slaves.
Even though it was a horrible thing to have happen, it happened hundreds of years ago.

ronop wrote on Aug 24, 2008 2:25 PM:

For a free will offering of zero dollars, I just became a minsiter with The Church of the seven planes (on the internet). I want a piece of the action and I plan to set up my marriage chappel across from the Mill Casino. I'll be specializing in the marriage of gays, lesbians, transgenders, ponies, and cross dressing politicians.

laura wrote on Aug 24, 2008 11:54 AM:

to mccain in==
comparing a pedephile to a gay person, well obviously you are just crazy. get real. this article has nothing to do with children and pedephiles. who cares if a man wants to be with a man or a women with a women, does it really affect us, no, who cares. hearing about gay marriage is getting really old. be with who you want to be, whoever you can love, and live a happy healthy life here on this earth for the one time you get to be here. you cannot judge people for who they fall in love with. who cares, thats their life.

Kris wrote on Aug 24, 2008 9:01 AM:

First I want to say that I support gay marriage. Not because I am gay (in fact I am a straight female). But because I see too many failed marriages from the heterosexual couples. I support gay marriage and gay adoption because they have to fight harder to make it happen or work. Because there are biggots like us out there standing in their way.

Leave them alone and support these couples instead of bashing them. Do any of you know them personally? You know this could be a member of YOUR family!

Sheila D. wrote on Aug 23, 2008 9:30 PM:

Congrats to Jeni & Kitzen!

And phooey on all you holier than thou's making a big stink of this, when it has no effect on your lives. As a child of divorce, I can tell you gays had NOTHING to do with the downfall of my heterosexual parents' marriage.

Those of you comparing gays marrying to children & animals ... You're showing your bigotry & ignorance more than you'll ever know. Stop making Coos County look like a bunch of backwoods hillbillies please.

usedtobe wrote on Aug 23, 2008 7:59 PM:

Question if there is a "gay marriage" what is "gay divorce"?

Dan wrote on Aug 23, 2008 5:04 PM:

The next goal is to strike down the unfair stigma attached to bestiality and polygamy and pederasty. If a guy wants to marry his two underaged gerbils, that shouldn't bother anyone. That way he can declare his love publicly. Of course, the rest of us should be compelled to watch and cheer.

C Shupp wrote on Aug 23, 2008 9:28 AM:

Goodness...I think the tribal God is supposed to be the same God I believe in. I believe the decisions we make as a country, like what we decide the laws are, our entire country will pay the price for. God is loving, He is also vengeful. We will all pay His price for abortion...murder, lying, not backing Israel, etc. He speaks against homosexuality. Guess what, we will all pay the price for what our country does. Most homosexuals twist what the bible says, anyone that wants to sin does. So what's the real issue here?

Coos Bay Person wrote on Aug 23, 2008 9:07 AM:

I believe each to there own, but I am tired of INDIAN TRIBES declaring they are a soverign nation everytime they want something there way.

Al the Pal wrote on Aug 23, 2008 8:19 AM:

Mr. Two Feathers

I have been on this earth 54 years. To my best recollection, I have never once stolen land from anyone. For that matter, i certainly don't recall owning or using anybody as a slave.

What I am aware, is getting sick and tired of those issues being used as an excuse for my paycheck being tapped into in order to offset those offenses.

Isn't is about time to try a different ploy.

How long do I have to pay for that?

There is not a single living Native American in this Country who was around to have land stolen from them, nor are there any former slaves.

Get over it.

McCain in wrote on Aug 23, 2008 7:43 AM:

WOW "To All You Who Say Yea": It must be tough being so fearful as you go through life!

McCain In wrote on Aug 23, 2008 7:40 AM:

"What if we allowed pedophiles to do this. Would it be okay then as they just have a sexual preference of children. ...
Where do we draw the line?
I totally support peoples sexual choices in the bedroom and in public so long as it doesn't affect others, and I believe the same for heterosexuals." as submitted by To All You Who Say Yea.

WOW! It must be tough being so fearful as you go through life!

K.C. Coquille wrote on Aug 23, 2008 6:14 AM:

The next barrier for the tribe to tackle is POLGAMY.

I don't know why anybody would want more than one spouse . . . . but,

But many peoples, cultures, religions, societies, sects, and cults throughout human existence have utilized, lived with, and endorsed the practice of multiple spouses.

Usually one gent with many wives, but sometimes one lady with a herd of stallions.

Just a thought . . . (though not necessarily a good one)!

Sean Two-Feathers Kellog wrote on Aug 23, 2008 3:09 AM:

I belong to a the Cherokee tribe. This is long overdue. We want to expand this law to include multiple partners. Perhaps three or four law abiding people in love should get the same respect for wanting to be recognized as a real family. Additionally, I honestly feel the age should be lowered to thirteen. That is the age that my people were married a century ago when the white man stole my land.

Member On The Fence wrote on Aug 23, 2008 1:13 AM:

I. I'm still on the fence about gay marriage, but I'm most surprisedby the lack of respect shown by those who "don't support" the CIT. I've heard respected community leaders make derogatory statements for 20 years.. Anyone remember the NB waterfront in 1994? EMPTY! We're not perfect, but the CIT has given back MILLIONS to this community & is the 2nd largest employer. Would be nice if this community could finally accept our heritage; stop hating the "darn Red Devils" for our success. I urgeyou to read our history. Learn of my ancestors- removed from their land, forced to march to Siletz then die of starvation or disease. Children were sent to "Indian" School-hair cut and forbidden to speak ourlanguage. The Mill Casino was built to provide our health programs and housing for our people- as it continues to today. We're all appreciate of these benefits, but mostly, we're proud to have helped our community prosper. Please know- CIT members are concerned about the recent policy on gay marriage. Like I said, I'm still on the fence.. but I'd like to think we could all agree- on some issues we'll never all agree. Thank you.

Kaye wrote on Aug 22, 2008 7:11 PM:

I support the tribe's decision. It certainly is a step in the right direction and gives me hope that we're not totally living in the boonies.
what the heck - looking at the divorce rates the one man/one woman thing doesn't really look like 100% success story.

Tobias wrote on Aug 22, 2008 7:10 PM:

I believe the tribe should be applauded and commended for standing up against discrimination in any shape or form!

There is nothing worse than prejudice especially combined with the ignorance of what this country really stands for and the many people who have sacrificed so much for our hard won rights.

Shawn wrote on Aug 22, 2008 6:40 PM:

"50% percent of first marriages, 67% of second and 74% of third marriages end in divorce, according to Jennifer Baker of the Forest Institute of Professional Psychology in Springfield, Missouri.” I think straight people have managed to screw up marriage long enough lets let gay people have a chance. Honestly it's none of anyone elses business.

Al the Pal wrote on Aug 22, 2008 6:12 PM:

I fully support gay marriages. Why shouldn't they be a miserable as the rest of us?

TOM wrote on Aug 22, 2008 3:17 PM:

Now it is time for all the straight people to go on the warpath. I can't believe that the "Tribe" did such a stupid thing.

pril wrote on Aug 22, 2008 3:13 PM:

oh yeah I almost forgot. The sky is falling the sky is falling!!!

mook wrote on Aug 22, 2008 11:37 AM:

People always talk about the sanctity of marriage. I mean come on now, you have people like Brittany Spears getting married for 55 hours. I believe that if two people love each other it shouldn't matter who they marry. Besides I myself am married (man/woman) and hell they can have it.

Coquille Member wrote on Aug 22, 2008 10:58 AM:

Tribal Member “this was never voted on by the tribe and was kept totally quite from anyone knowing this was happening."
As a Coquille tribal member I know that this was not kept quite. This issue was brought up at a General Council meeting. It was then part of two papers that were sent out to the tribe as an over view of follow up to the General Council meeting. Furthermore it was published in the Tribal Tidbits that Tribal Council was considering this ordinance (as all ordinances are) and given a comment period longer than most ordinances receive so that tribal members could voice their opinions. This Ordinance was treated like all other ordinances.

One opinion wrote on Aug 22, 2008 10:56 AM:

To "here we go":
Are you kidding me with the "kids will be teased, if they have same sex parents"...I have kids in school and these days kids get teased for EVERYTHING, so I doubt being raised by two people of the same sex will make much difference. Also, I see heterosexual people making out and I don't want to see that either...PDA should be kept in private....this is not a same sex issue, this is just some things need to be kept in the privacy of your own home.....I think its great if two people want to commit to each other regardless of their sex when we are in a society now where marriage is treated like a disposable cup....when you're done with it, just throw it away! And oh yeah, Christians who judge...I am sure those of you who are quoting the bible have not lived up to your end of the bargain all the time either...check the person sitting next to you in the pew on Sunday, probably the same person dancing and leaving the bar with someone other than their spouse on the Saturday night before asking for forgiveness on Sunday morning.

supporter wrote on Aug 22, 2008 10:43 AM:

Who are you people to tell others how to interpret the bible, the bible also says thou shall not judge and that's exactly what all of you are doing.

And gay is not a "choice" one makes or a "sexual experiment" it is just who they are, the way they were born.

Coos Bay Kid wrote on Aug 22, 2008 10:07 AM:

Again...don't accept this lifestyle as normal. Go with your gut feeling. Homosexuality is gross and wrong. I refuse to let my morals go backwards. I hope the recall is successful. Native Americans need to take a stand against this and contact their representatives.

Voice of Reason wrote on Aug 22, 2008 9:49 AM:

The government should get out of the "marriage" business altogether. If you want to get "married" - go to a church. From the government/legal perspective - "marriage" should amount to a contract and nothing more. And contracts can be formed between any willing, competent adult parties. The latter point takes out all the spurious arguments regarding marrying children, dogs, objects, etc.

Marriage should be defined/recognized by religious/spiritual/moral institutions as they see fit.

No..We dont all read the Bible wrote on Aug 22, 2008 9:24 AM:

ROSEBURG wrote on Aug 21, 2008 3:50 PM:
HOW CAN YOU ALLOW GAY MARRIAGE. DOES ANYONE NOT READ THE BIBLE ANYMORE. IT SAYS SPECIFICALLY MAN AND WOMAN, NOT MAN AND MAN OR WOMAN AND WOMAN. I HOPE YOU ALL COME TO YOUR SENSES BEFORE YOU ALL MAKE THE WORLD COME TO AN END.

No...we don't all read the bible. We are not all Christian. We are a country with many diverse spiritual beliefs. Some religions teach love and acceptance of all living beings because within each is the divine creator.

Sovereign Nation wrote on Aug 22, 2008 9:15 AM:

Tribal sovereignty refers to the inherent authority of indigenous tribes to govern themselves.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tribal_sovereignty
The tribe can make whatever laws they want and enforce them.

My question is why don't they drill for oil and build a refinery?
They would be making a lot more money doing that than CASINOS!

pril wrote on Aug 22, 2008 9:06 AM:

Lets just make marriage illegal. Then we won't have to squabble over who's allowed to get married. No one could get married. That'd be great. Humans not allowed to marry each other. Fabulous!

E wrote on Aug 22, 2008 8:31 AM:

Fred Derf, you don't see many old gay people in NB/CB because you guys ran them all off along with African Americans about 50 years ago. Isn't it just ducky having the KKK outside of town?

All Right wrote on Aug 22, 2008 8:25 AM:

All the objections will be moot in a couple of years. Hallmark is issuing Gay Marriage Cards! I love it! If Hallmark says its ok - who is to argue?
And, Oh please, do not quote the Bible - I violate biblical laws each time I eat an Oyster! If you are going to quote the Old Testament, live by all its laws (I dare you to keep Kosher - hope you aren't eating Crab - the pig of the sea).
Congratulations and Best Wishes.

Just Me wrote on Aug 22, 2008 8:21 AM:

I think some very good points have been made on this post. Our country did rebel against forced religion. Marriage has lost its value over time, not by gays but by those who have had the privilege to be married. How do you explain it to your children? Easy, YOU TALK TO THEM!

I am disgusted at those of you who are professing Christianity as a reason for acting superior to others. You use your belief to put yourself above others and as an excuse for just about any ugly or ignorant act, past or present, that you and your fellow Christians commit. If this were what one must do to be a Christian, why would any good people want to be a part of it? It is a shame to dishonor the name of God this way.

To NB: No need for God to judge, it sounds like you have already done that for him.

concerned wrote on Aug 22, 2008 7:54 AM:

Lisa, the Hebrew word for Kill in the Old testament literally means "Murder". It isn't referring to war, which, after the fall of man, became a sad necessity for the rule of man.

The rule of law in America is that marriage is one man, one woman. That is the issue, and the tribe is just wielding their non-citizenship in the face of the American government.

It must be nice to do whatever you please in the name of sovereignty, but still enjoy the conveniences of a free nation.

Samuel wrote on Aug 22, 2008 7:51 AM:

I have read all of the comments and I agree with most of the them! I am a Christian and Proud to be one!!! I am not a judge nor a jury. I was not placed on earth to do that. I do not agree with the lifestyle myself, and I most certainly would not cast a ballot saying that it is ok with what I know today. People should be treated fairly regardless of what their personal thoughts are. The Government is already trying to restrict Christians from their belief, I think we should not be too fast to restrict others beliefs providing nobody else is getting hurt. Yet we have come to this point when unemployment and homelessness has made the very bottom of the pages in the paper and are not being addressed like they should be. We need to get back to the issues the plague societys exsistance. There are too many more problems that are really forefront of things right now instead of private matters. Interpret that as you will!

CBNative wrote on Aug 22, 2008 6:17 AM:

If anybody knows what discrimination feels like it is the Native American. We have had to fight for our own rights for as long as the EuroAmericans have roamed this country.These women have a right to be recognized as a married couple They are not asking for anything more than what everyone else takes for granted.

Jim wrote on Aug 22, 2008 6:15 AM:

If homosexuality is an affront to God, then let God decide how to deal with it. Stay out of these people's business. It's none of yours.

America. wrote on Aug 22, 2008 1:36 AM:

I'm tired of these Indians.

Why don't they all just go home?

LN wrote on Aug 22, 2008 12:49 AM:

I think gay people are awesome!!!!!!! I am happy its being excepted. what happened to love??? obviously the ones who are against it are soooo full of hate and judgement their the ones on their 3rd marriages. I think it is great if people are happy and in love who cares!

Melissa wrote on Aug 22, 2008 12:48 AM:

LINDA,
Maybe it should say Adam and Adam or Eve and Eve then maybe Adam wouldnt have listened to Adam or Eve wouldnt have listen to Eve then the world would have been a different place!!!!

Melissa wrote on Aug 22, 2008 12:44 AM:

CORA,
So you tell me that children are going to get confused if they see two people of they same sex making out? Hello this is 2008 where have you been if your children have no clue about same sex partners then go to the video store and rent BROKE BACK MOUNTAIN great education lol

Melissa wrote on Aug 22, 2008 12:39 AM:

Then again why would there be gay people raising staight peoples kids hmmm lets see!!! I really hate this straight people gay people thing i think no matter who you are you are HUMAN and i dont believe any straight person has even the right to vote when it comes to gay marriage it has nothing to do with us!!! So SEANDAVID I miss you and love you lots oh yeah something else if you have a gay friend male or female you will find that they are the best friends you will ever have and if you dont have a gay friend you are missing out!!!!!

Melissa wrote on Aug 22, 2008 12:33 AM:

SEANDAVID,
I totally agree with you,Let me tell you people a little something i am a married (to a man) women with 2 kids and i have alot of gay friends. One of my gay friend Keith whom has passed away was a foster parent and a great one at that he took a BOY in and raised him to be a straight young man and we heard more than once that gay people should have child because they would end up gay is a load of crap!!!! out of room will post more

Tribal members wrote on Aug 21, 2008 11:33 PM:

As Tribal members we are very up set with the four Council members who voted for the gay marriage issue. The majority of the Tribal members do not agree. There is talk of a recall for the four that voted for this measure

another tax payer wrote on Aug 21, 2008 9:58 PM:

Oh my gosh do you even have a clue? The tribe is the 2nd largest employer in coos county. Where would all these people make their money, if not for the tribe? I kind of wish the tribe would actually take over for the county there democratically elected government functions well and listens to it's people. They have a police dept. that actually comes to there peoples houses when called upon, and they do so in a timely manner. They have also enterened into an agreement with coos county to help bring back timber revenue. So maybe before people blurt out a bunch of unfactual information they should do a little research and not prove how redneck this county really is.

Here We Go wrote on Aug 21, 2008 9:20 PM:

Kitzen and Jeni, Each to their own, but do us a favor and keep the AFFECTIONS in the privacy of your "OWN" home. Our small children don't need to see it. As in the words of Jackie Gleason, "What in the heck is the world comming to". I sincerly hope neither one of these people have children in the school system, because they will be teased. TO:Concerned, I also agree with you!

Bon wrote on Aug 21, 2008 8:50 PM:

YUCK!!!!!

I thought.. wrote on Aug 21, 2008 8:15 PM:

Pursuit of happyness was an unalienable right.
If two people of the same sex want to get hitched and it'll make them happy..so what? Let them get hitched.
It's in the constitution and state and church should be separated so you really shouldn't bring up the bible with all of this.
And Christians are supposed to love everyone no matter what sexual orientation or color or religion.
So if you're really into the bible you shouldn't hate them.

Tribal Member wrote on Aug 21, 2008 8:11 PM:

Just to let everyone know that as a Tribal member I was horified when I read this article. Dont judge the whole tribe because of this unmoral tribal law allowing gays to marry as this was never voted on by the tribe and was kept totally quite from anyone knowing this was happening. I think as a very dissappointed member perhaps it is time the members of the Tribe stand up for our ancestors morals and if that takes changing the current Tribal council so be it. Shame on you Ttribal Council, what were you thinking?

old time north bend wrote on Aug 21, 2008 7:16 PM:

i wonder if they will get a grant to pay for it.

Again wrote on Aug 21, 2008 6:17 PM:

Again, the silly tax issue? Call the City of North Bend and ask them how much the Tribe's payment was to them last year. Tribes are domestic dependent nations, and they are sovereign. Look at it this way...at least they never sued you to recover all of the land your ancestors stole.

Coos Bay Kid wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:53 PM:

Gay marriage makes about as much sense as driving a car without an engine. It's so wrong that we try and justify it to make it right. "We live in a new ers." What BS. Open your eyes people. Don't let the liberal media determine your though process on what is right and wrong. Physically look at two people of the same sex. Now think....Exactly....Marriage is clearly between a man and a woman. Don't accept this lifestyle as "normal." It's not. The Coquille Indian Tribe has done alot of good things. They got this one wrong.

Lisa wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:50 PM:

It's the current REPUBLICAN government that is ruining this country, not gay marriage. If you want to live by the rules, why don't you start with the first commandment:

Thou Shall Not Kill

No, all you Bush/War supporters skip that rule, don't you??

If you're not gay this doesn't concern you! If you're too stupid to explain to kids that there are gay people in this world then perhaps social services should pay you a visit and remove your little ones.

ex-Coos Bay wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:48 PM:

Cora- I really hope I never see you slobbering all over someone in public, what would I tell my children?!

NB and Roseburg- First, learn how to use grammar (go to college?). Second, the bible is not the constitution. Not everyone here is a christian, and not all christians are bigots like you. Jesus is frowning upon your intolerance, not two woman who love each other. Quit quoting your little bible because it is irrelevant in our secular legal system. Better yet, move to Iran if you want a theocracy and persecution of homosexuals.

stop the insanity wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:30 PM:

Libby, the pig was a well kept secret. My dog reads the World online and will now know. He's got a heck of an overbite.

BOB wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:28 PM:

To all who claim this isn't right because we voted on it in Oregon read the following sentence and then look up sovereign nation...you may wipe away some of you ignorance by doing this. Congratulations to the couple.


"Oregon voters amended the state constitution in 2004 to prohibit gay marriage. But as a federally recognized sovereign nation, the tribe is not bound by the Oregon Constitution."

progress wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:27 PM:

Wow, I am positively amazed! This is a step forward for tolerance and human rights. To all the people who are "appalled" you need to mind your own business and get over it, discrimination is morally wrong. Your dog is not the same as a consenting adult with mutual love so your "clever" little metaphor is baseless.

taxpayer wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:23 PM:

Oh my Gosh, why don't we just let the Coquille Indians run the whole darn area here. They can do anything they want and not pay one dime of taxes to help our area in any way, they should take the good with the bad as we all do, but all they do is TAKE and now this, I just can't stand it anymore. Just let them take the whole area over and make all their own laws, thats what they are doing anyway.....

Cora wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:18 PM:

To Seandavid, it does meddle when someones little kid wants to know why 2 guys or 2 girls are slobbering all over each other in public. Don't think that that's confusing? If not you are confused.

Linda wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:15 PM:

I think this kind of stuff is getting so out of hand. I mean like the girl who wanted to be a guy and then has a baby(from Oregon). I wonder what people in the other states and Oprah thought of Oregonians. Now that's redneck? Now you tell me there's not something wrong upstairs. Where does it say Adam and Adam or Eve and Eve? No wonder our kids are confused.

Fred Derf wrote on Aug 21, 2008 4:12 PM:

Its hard to believe that this is creating such an outcry over something as simple as sexual experimentation. Gay people try this then eventually realize it isn't natural then move on. How many old Gay people do you know?? Not to many, because they either straighten them selves out or contract some awful disease. I say leave them alone and let them do what they want. They can deal with the eventual divorces when its time.

NB wrote on Aug 21, 2008 3:56 PM:

Just all the more reason why I am looking forward to our Lord's return to judge this perverted sin.

Roseburg wrote on Aug 21, 2008 3:50 PM:

HOW CAN YOU ALLOW GAY MARRIAGE. DOES ANYONE NOT READ THE BIBLE ANYMORE. IT SAYS SPECIFICALLY MAN AND WOMAN, NOT MAN AND MAN OR WOMAN AND WOMAN. I HOPE YOU ALL COME TO YOUR SENSES BEFORE YOU ALL MAKE THE WORLD COME TO AN END.

Libby University wrote on Aug 21, 2008 3:13 PM:

"Another reason why I don't support the Tribe or any of it's affiliations"
+1
"I love my dog. He frequently tries to walk in my shoes. Will the tribe marry us also."

Only if you can either
1. Buy your way into the tribe
2. Show you're not living out of wedlock with Bessie the pig

Coos Bay native in PDX wrote on Aug 21, 2008 3:12 PM:

Congrats to the Coquille Tribe for understanding that discrimination is not a family value! As for those who think this will "ruin marriage for the rest of us", I think the 60% divorce rate among the heterosexuals has already done that.

Congrats ladies!!!

SeanDavid wrote on Aug 21, 2008 3:08 PM:

I want just at least one provable example of how Gay Marriage has Made America Weak. As far as I know America has become weak under the rule of straight people . Dont Blame us for your short commings, and Failed Wedding Vows.

SeanDavid wrote on Aug 21, 2008 3:01 PM:

Gay Taxes pay for the same rights and previleges as Straight taxes and should have the same rights. Thank you Ko`Kwel Tribe. and for those who dont agree with those who want the same rights, well thats just too bad, Na Na Na Na Naaaaa Na. What gay people do doesnt meddle in to your private lives, so treat people as you want to be treated, and Take care of your own Straight married lives of which 1 out of 2 FAIL!

Go for it wrote on Aug 21, 2008 2:50 PM:

I was raised in a deeply religious family and finally opened my eyes and saw that many of the same "community" were gay and suffering because of our intolerance. I have no problems with gays marrying, I am just sorry we "straights" have made such a joke of marriage. As for the country being "founded" on religious principle - people need to read the history of our founding fathers - they were rebelling not only against England but enforced religion - They were a pretty diverse lot.

shocked by response wrote on Aug 21, 2008 2:39 PM:

it appears that most people posting their comments to this story know nothing about history! of course the elders would support this! and good luck with the supposed founding of America based on Christianity - sounds nice.... too bad the Native Americans were here first! I'm not a Coquille Tribe Member but will support them and their businesses more because of this.

Grace wrote on Aug 21, 2008 2:28 PM:

I have friends that are gay. I consider them family. I would go to their wedding if I was invited. And I would have a wonderful time. But I can't help feeling that it is not the way nature intended for us to live. I can credit that to living with a chatholic upbringing and being Native. I don't understand how a council of tribal members would allow something like this unless one of them are gay.

MsV wrote on Aug 21, 2008 2:20 PM:

Congratulations to the happy couple! Don't let closed-minded people get you down. There's plenty of us who support rights for ALL people, not just the people with the biggest mouths. Have a long and happy life together :)

RJ wrote on Aug 21, 2008 2:17 PM:

Stop the Insanity says, with corrected punctuation, "I love my dog. He frequently tries to walk in my shoes. Will the tribe marry us also.(?)"
I say, only if your dog is a willing partner.
Please, keep the laughs coming.

Jess B. wrote on Aug 21, 2008 2:17 PM:

Now a comment not directed at the happy couple.
To