Chris Guernsey has a rather unorthodox method for walking her son's dog, Bubba. She drives a short distance from her home on Telegraph Hill, lets out the 10-year-old mixed beagle, then slowly motors back, with Bubba trotting alongside.
Having performed this routine for several years, Guernsey said her neighbors have grown accustomed to this sight. But the spectacle that unfolded Father's Day morning raised a few eyebrows, including Guernsey's.
It was a little after 10 a.m., when a blur of brown, black and white bolted up the Guernseys' steep driveway. Guernsey and her husband, Jud, who were awaiting their son's arrival, at first weren't sure what they were seeing.
“Jud said, ‘Look, Bubba's chasing a deer. No wait. The deer's chasing Bubba!'” Chris recalled. “It was absolutely flabbergasting.”
“I'd never seen him run so fast. All four legs were going, two at a time, and the deer was right behind.”
With the deer nipping at his back, Bubba raced up the stairs to the Guernsey's front door. Eyeing the steps cautiously, the 3-foot-tall deer pulled back and trotted up the hill, back down, across the driveway and back up the street.
“It happened so fast. It started, ended and then it was gone,” Chris said.
The full story came when John Guernsey, their son, arrived. He said he had stopped at the intersection of Third Court and Date Avenue so Bubba could get some exercise before arriving at his “grandparents'” place. But as soon as he had let Bubba out, a deer materialized, seemingly out of nowhere, and the chase began.
John piled back into his car and drove down the street a ways, finding Bubba cowering under a pickup truck with an attached trailer. The deer was nowhere in sight. After some cajoling, John was able to convince Bubba it was safe to come out.
But, it wasn't.
As stealthily as it had appeared before, the deer re-emerged, sending Bubba on his mad rush for the Guernseys' front door.
Once inside, Bubba took a good while to calm down.
“He's an old dog and he had a real fright,” Chris said. “Usually he gets a drink of water after a walk, but it took him two and a half hours before he got up. It was quite stressful.”
Black-tailed deer are not an uncommon sight on Telegraph Hill. Guernsey said she has frequently seen deer munching on blackberry vines and apple tree leaves. This year, deer have been especially plentiful, Guernsey said, noting she has seen a doe with a buck and a fawn, as well as another doe with two fawns.
“We are always tickled to see one,” Chris said, though she never had seen one attack a dog.
In hindsight, Guernsey suspected Bubba just happened to be too close to a momma deer and her young.
That assessment was shared by Bill Kinyoun, assistant district wildlife biologist in the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife's Charleston office.
“Typically what's happening here is someone allows dogs to roam and does have their fawns nearby, and they get very protective,” he said. “If a deer feels it is being threatened, it will go after a dog.”
Kinyoun said it is not uncommon for deer to attack dogs, or even people. In the last two weeks, he said he had been called out twice to deal with deer attacking both. Unlike the case on Telegraph Hill, the other two deer had been taken as pets when they were fawns. But once they got older, they became aggressive.
“What people tend to forget is they are wild animals. What's cute and cuddly when it's young grows up and they have lost their fear of the human environment,” Kinyoun said. “They try to establish an order of domination, just like they would in a deer herd.”
When Kinyoun is called in to take care of an aggressive deer, he will give the offending ruminant tranquilizers, take it to an isolated area and euthanize it.
A recent incident in Reedsport served as a prime example why that is the ODFW protocol, Kinyoun said. After corralling a 1-year-old buck that had been living as a pet since being captured as a fawn, Kinyoun and a partner headed to Elliott State Forest to dispatch the animal, but they had a change of heart.
“We had a soft spot and we talked ourselves into turning it loose,” he said.
They left the deer some food and waited until the tranquilizers had worn off before leaving. Kinyoun expected the deer would serve as a bear's dinner since it had been living in a human environment for so long. But that wasn't to be the case.
“Four days later, we got a call from Loon Lake, which is 10 miles from where we dropped it off, and it was doing the same thing,” Kinyoun said.
U.S. Bureau of Land Management personnel had captured the buck in a compound, but needed Kinyoun to take care of it. Unlike before, when it went much more quietly, the buck put up a good fight before it was tranquilized. Kinyoun said he broke a rib as a result of the effort.
“Which just goes to show that no good deed will go unpunished,” he said.
Kinyoun expects to continue receiving aggressive deer complaints the rest of the summer, when does are especially protective of their young, and into fall, when bucks begin to rut.
Since Father's Day, there have be no more incidents on Telegraph Hill, Guernsey said, though Bubba is a little more cautious these days when he comes to visit.
“Now he looks very carefully to see if there are any deer,” Chris Guernsey said with a laugh.
The comments below are from users of theworldlink.com and do not necessarily represent the views of The World or Lee Enterprises. Participation Guidelines
Note: There is a maximum of 200 words per comment. If you wish to post more, please visit our forum.
Comment Policy
The World welcomes your comments about stories, and we encourage a robust dialogue on this site. All comments must meet reasonable standards of decency and civility.
Please follow these basic rules:
No defamatory comments about individuals or businesses.
No deliberately false information.
No obscenity or racially offensive language.
No harassment, verbal abuse, threats or personal attacks.
No information that invades another person's privacy.
No business solicitations or charitable solicitations.
Comments that violate these standards will not be posted. Users with repeated violations may be banned from future posting.
Comments will be approved throughout the day during business hours. After hours and weekend comments may not appear until the following business day. It may take a couple of hours before comments are approved.
The World generally does not edit comments, but we reserve the right to edit any comment that does not meet our standards.
Aggressive deer!? I think it all depends on how one looks at this. This is wildlife! Get it...."wild.....life". It is a life that is wild. Instinct to protect is similar to human behavior. Hint, hint! Accept things are not always going to be the way YOU think they should be. The idea of constantly resorting to KILLING shows how limited one's thinking is. Is that the easy way out of an inconvenience? I suppose, "loser" would be a better word to define one who thinks the immediate answer to inconvenience is to kill! Take a class on ethics please. Do the world a favor. My God, have mercy on this world as long as there are people who constantly resort to killing your creatures.
In all fairness to two writers who are criticized by "The Mom" for defending the deer with a fawn, it DID say in the article, and I quote: 'In hindsight, Guernsey suspected Bubba just happened to be too close to a momma deer and her young.', hence the conclusion. Poor old Bubba, I'm sure it was a big scare to an old do - but dogs do attack deer, so it may have been the deer's reaction to having been harrassed by a dog previously....I'd say, always be aware of wildlife and don't leave your pets unsuipervised at any time.
How would anyone know it was the same "offending" deer that kept attacking? I didn't realize that each deer can be so easily recognized from another deer...DUH!
I think it's about time that the deer everywhere fight back for being used as living targets, pincushions, and scapegoats for every problem that is blamed on them....
I'm not saying that it was right to put that deer down but the reason given by the previous 2 posters was NOT what I read in the story. The article mentions "aggressive deer" then gives a "prime example":
"After corralling a 1-year-old buck that had been living as a pet since being captured as a fawn, Kinyoun and a partner headed to Elliott State Forest to dispatch the animal, but they had a change of heart."
Nowhere in this story does it say that this particular deer has a fawn and was protecting it, only that is was captured AS A FAWN and had since been raised as a pet. So, even after sparing it's life, the deer continued it's aggressive behavior. Dogs that turn aggressive are put down all the time, especially when they start attacking without provocation.
Wow - I couldn't agree more with the first post! It seems absolutely asinine to kill an "offending ruminant" for protecting its fawn! What's even more puzzling and idiculous, is the reference to the deer that was raised as a pet and released as a one-year old; how it would likely become a bear's dinner...Are these people insane? An animal raised from very young (referred to as a pet in this case), no matter what species, cannot be released into the wild unless it was properly rehabilitated by a professional wildlife rehabber - have they ever heard of such a thing? This is Oregon, not some third-world country! Where are wildlife agencies on the issue of releasing any tame species of wildlife? Most states, as I would hope that Oregon also subscribes to, require anyone who keeps a wild animal to be licensed as a rehabilitator in order not to allow this sort of thing to happen. That poor animal, having been raised as a pet, only to be killed by those that it ame to trust. How despicable! This is nothing but narrowminded bureaucracy!
http://www.m-w.com/cgi-bin/dictionary?book=Dictionary&va=euthanasia - Merriam-Webster online distionary definition of euthanasia. "Greek, easy death, from euthanatos: the act or practice of killing or permitting the death of hopelessly sick or injured individuals (as persons or domestic animals) in a relatively painless way for reasons of mercy."
Does anyone see the absolute ridiculousness of the following statement: "When Kinyoun is called in to take care of an aggressive deer, he will give the offending ruminant tranquilizers, take it to an isolated are and euthanize it." First of all, this is NOT euthanasia, it is nothing more than plain stupidity, or to be kinder, ignorance, to kill an animal that is NOT suffering of any illness but merely defending its young, as stated as a reason for aggression toward humans and in this case, a dog. Because the animal is defending its young, it becomes an "offending ruminant"! And if this is done with such human kindness, why does the animal need to be taken to an isolated area in order to be slaughtered needlessly - could it be that people might object, seeing the supidity and senselessness of this whole exercise? The article points out the insensitivity and "logic" of wildlife agencies - kill anything that even slightly inconvenience anyone in the community. I'd be more worried about tranquilizer and gun-toting members of the community mistaking anyone or their pets as "offending ruminants"!
The World welcomes your comments about stories, and we encourage a robust dialogue on this site. All comments must meet reasonable standards of decency and civility.
Please follow these basic rules:
- No defamatory comments about individuals or businesses.
- No deliberately false information.
- No obscenity or racially offensive language.
- No harassment, verbal abuse, threats or personal attacks.
- No information that invades another person's privacy.
- No business solicitations or charitable solicitations.
Comments that violate these standards will not be posted. Users with repeated violations may be banned from future posting.Comments will be approved throughout the day during business hours. After hours and weekend comments may not appear until the following business day. It may take a couple of hours before comments are approved.
The World generally does not edit comments, but we reserve the right to edit any comment that does not meet our standards.
Close Guidelines